Chart A Course for Success
Shipmate Update
Captain Homeschool • 06/01/2026
Captain’s Riddles — Solutions
Elementary: Captain Abe suspected Cabin Boy Timmy. Ms. Pennington’s hands were covered in greasy polish, so she couldn’t have touched a cookie. Timmy, however, had flour on his nose (suggesting he was in the galley where the cookies were, or where baking happens) and a cookie crumb on his cheek, which is a clear sign he just ate one.
Middle School: Captain Abe suspected Cabin Boy Leo. Leo claimed he scrubbed the deck from sunset until midnight. However, Captain Abe observed that the deck was still wet in the morning. This implies Leo either continued scrubbing past midnight or was lying about when he finished. If he was still scrubbing after midnight, he would have had the opportunity to go near the locker when no one else was likely around. Ms. Pennington’s alibi of being in the crow’s nest all night checks out.
High School: Captain Abe suspected Ms. Pennington. Here’s why: 1. Captain Abe distinctly remembers securing the sextant in its box inside the chartroom at 9 PM. 2. Ms. Pennington claims she also placed the sextant back in its box inside the chartroom at 9 PM, after Captain Abe. Only one person could have performed this final action. 3. Most critically, Ms. Pennington states, “I went straight to my bunk for the night. I never left my cabin until 6 AM to go on deck and found it there.” 4. Master Carpenter Gus, from his vantage point in the crow’s nest (8 PM to 2 AM), reported seeing “no one going in or out” of the chartroom door. 5. If Ms. Pennington placed the sextant inside the chartroom at 9 PM and Gus saw no one leave the chartroom until 2 AM, then the sextant should have remained inside the chartroom. 6. Therefore, Ms. Pennington’s claim that she “never left my cabin until 6 AM” must be false, because if she didn’t leave her cabin, and no one else entered or exited the chartroom, the sextant could not have moved from inside to on deck. She must have taken it out herself sometime after 9 PM. The small scuff mark at floor level on the chartroom doorframe further suggests that something was dragged out of the chartroom, supporting the idea that the heavy sextant box was forcibly removed.
Past Editions Archive
Download previous issues of the Shipmate Update.





Captain Homeschool